The Short Answer: Color Is the Only Difference
If you're comparing XK-143 and XK-146, you're looking at the same Large Xymon's Knot design in the same Medium (0050) silicone. The only catalog difference is the color selection: XK-143 comes in pink, aqua, or purple, while XK-146 comes in blue or purple. Every measurement, firmness rating, and design feature is identical between the two product IDs.
That means your decision comes down to which color you prefer, plus whether you want the extra aqua or pink option that XK-143 offers. Below, we break down the shared specs so you can confirm the size and feel are right for you before choosing a colorway.
Shared Measurements: What You Get with Either Model
- Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-143: Total length: 8 inches; useable length: 6.5 inches These are the overall and insertable lengths, so you can judge whether the toy suits your space and preferences.

Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-143 - Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-143: Diameter of the head: 2.25 inches; circumference of the head: 7.5 inches The head is the first point of insertion, so its girth is a key comfort checkpoint.
- Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-143: Widest shaft diameter: 2.75 inches; circumference of the shaft: 7.5 inches The shaft's widest point tells you how much stretch the main body requires.
- Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-143: Widest knot diameter: 2.9 inches; circumference of the knot: 8.5 inches The knot is the thickest part of the design, so this measurement is the real challenge point.
- Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-143: Base diameter: 4 inches A wider base can help stability and grip, especially since the listing notes the toy may have trouble staying upright in softer silicone.
Firmness and Handling: Medium (0050) Silicone
Both XK-143 and XK-146 are cast in Medium (0050) silicone. The listing describes this as a medium firmness, and it notes that the toy may have trouble staying upright in softer silicone—so Medium is the only firmness offered for these two IDs. The base has grooves designed to make gripping easier, which is worth knowing if you plan to use the toy hands-free or need extra control during insertion.
Because the knot is the widest point at 2.9 inches in diameter (8.5 inches circumference), the Medium silicone will feel firm enough to hold its shape but still have some give. The listing does not provide a shore hardness comparison beyond the 0050 rating, so if you're used to other firmness scales, treat this as a moderate firmness rather than a soft or firm extreme.
Color Options: Where the Two Models Diverge
- Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-143: Color: pink, aqua, purple XK-143 gives you three color choices, including pink and aqua, which are not available on XK-146.
- Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-146: Color: blue, purple XK-146 offers blue or purple, so if you prefer blue over pink or aqua, this is the model to choose.

Large Xymon's Knot -- Medium silicone -- XK-146
Design Details That Carry Across Both Models
The Large Xymon's Knot design features a tip with four smaller points that twists down into a thick shaft atop a veiny knot. The surface is full of varied textures, which the listing describes as a fun challenge for those seeking one. Both XK-143 and XK-146 share this exact shape and texture profile—only the pigment changes.
Because the design is identical, any cleaning, storage, or compatibility guidance you find for one model applies to the other. The listings do not include specific cleaning instructions or material compatibility details beyond the silicone firmness, so check the store's general silicone care page for guidance before first use.
Side-by-Side: XK-143 vs XK-146
- XK-143: Large Xymon's Knot in Medium (0050) silicone; colors: pink, aqua, purple; total length 8 inches, useable length 6.5 inches, head diameter 2.25 inches, widest shaft diameter 2.75 inches, knot diameter 2.9 inches, base diameter 4 inches.
- XK-146: Large Xymon's Knot in Medium (0050) silicone; colors: blue, purple; same measurements as XK-143: total length 8 inches, useable length 6.5 inches, head diameter 2.25 inches, widest shaft diameter 2.75 inches, knot diameter 2.9 inches, base diameter 4 inches.
How to Choose Between XK-143 and XK-146
Start with color preference. If you want pink or aqua, XK-143 is your only option. If you want blue, XK-146 is the one. Purple is available on both, so if purple is your pick, either model works—choose based on availability or any other factor that matters to you.
Next, confirm the size works for you. The 2.9-inch knot diameter is the widest point, and the 8.5-inch knot circumference is a significant girth. Compare that to toys you already own and enjoy. If you're new to knotted toys, the Medium firmness may feel intense at the knot, so take your time and use plenty of lubricant.
Finally, note that the listing warns the toy may have trouble staying upright in softer silicone. Since both models are Medium, this is less of a concern than with a soft silicone version, but the grooved base is there to help with grip if you need it.



